• INVESTORS
  • ABOUT US
    • INVESTMENTS
    • EDUCATION >
      • EDUCATION MEDIA
      • ECOSYSTEM RESOURCES
    • CONTACT US
  • ENTREPRENEURS
  • EVENTS
  • MEMBER LOGIN
ATA
  • INVESTORS
  • ABOUT US
    • INVESTMENTS
    • EDUCATION >
      • EDUCATION MEDIA
      • ECOSYSTEM RESOURCES
    • CONTACT US
  • ENTREPRENEURS
  • EVENTS
  • MEMBER LOGIN

Blog

From the Experts: Could the Samsung v. Apple Ruling Benefit Startups?

8/4/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
R. Lee Strasburger, Jr. Morris, Manning & Martin, LLP​
The U.S. Supreme Court’s upcoming review of patent damages in Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Apple Inc. shouldn’t be dreaded by the startup community. Within the last decade, the Supreme Court has weighed in on more patent-related cases than it has in the previous four decades combined. These rulings have impacted the tech community in various ways, mainly that it’s now more difficult to receive utility patent protection for certain technologies (e.g., fintech, etc.). That being said, many of the Supreme Court’s recent decisions have transformed ​patent trolls into mere paper tigers by reducing the profitability of patent litigation.
Whatever the Supreme Court decides during its next term, keep in mind that the ruling will cut both ways. While total profits awards for design patents could spur troll-litigation, design patents could equally become more valuable to the startup community.
Traditionally, design patents have been overlooked and/or undervalued by potential investors and the business community as a whole, because among other reasons, these types of patents protect design elements and not the actual science behind the technology (as do utility patents). Design patents, however, are generally cheaper to obtain than utility patents, making them more affordable to startups. Similarly, for those technologies that do not easily yield themselves to utility patents but are a common focus of startups (e.g., mobile apps, SaaS platforms, etc.), design patents provide a way to protect novel design features that represent functionally that otherwise cannot be effectively protected. So, if the Supreme Court upholds total profits awards for design patents, then startups will have a new way to increase valuations by creating barriers to entry to prevent others from copying their innovative designs.
1For reference, an example of a design patent can be found   here, which is one of Apple’s design patents at issue in the Supreme Court case.
1 Comment
Martha link
12/29/2020 04:21:02 am

This is greatt

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    April 2018
    August 2016

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Picture

ABOUT US

We are one of the nation’s top angel investing networks.  This includes members and VC affiliates in Atlanta and across the Southeast that work together to evaluate and fund early-stage companies.  Our mission is to provide opportunities for members to invest in top tier early-stage companies in the Southeast.  ATA members provide seed and early-stage capital to entrepreneurs seeking between $200K-$2M.  This is an investment range not generally served by venture capital funds and serves as a catalyst that helps to build the region's economy into a thriving center of technology and entrepreneurship.  Alongside financial support, we provide mentorship, industry expertise and valuable contacts.  We are looking to invest in high growth technology companies from numerous industries.  Atlanta Technology Angels & Gwinnett Angels screen Hardware, Software, Digital Media, Consumer Products and Services, Financial Services, Life Science, Healthcare, CleanTech and Industrial technologies.
  • INVESTORS
  • ABOUT US
    • INVESTMENTS
    • EDUCATION >
      • EDUCATION MEDIA
      • ECOSYSTEM RESOURCES
    • CONTACT US
  • ENTREPRENEURS
  • EVENTS
  • MEMBER LOGIN